23 November 2026

Yet beneath that competitive backdrop, there are growing signs that the conditions supporting continued rate reductions are becoming increasingly difficult to sustain. Claims inflation remains elevated, repair costs are still stubbornly high and underwriting margins continue to be under pressure.

Against that backdrop, a growing body of market commentary, combined with the conversations many of us are having across the market, suggests that the second half of 2027 could mark the beginning of a shift towards a more disciplined underwriting environment.

 

 

Whilst a return to hard market conditions is by no means certain, there are increasing signs that the current soft cycle may be reaching its natural limits.

Many of the factors that drove premium increases in previous years have returned, while some never went away. Yet premiums have continued to fall. At some point, that disconnect becomes difficult to justify.

 

The pressures beneath the soft market

Recent analysis from Oxbow Partners points to continued competition across the wider UK motor insurance market, but also highlights a growing gap between premium movements and underlying claims costs. Markets can tolerate that disconnect for a period, but rarely indefinitely. 

Although the Oxbow report looks at the wider motor market rather than fleet specifically, the pressures it identifies reflect many of the conversations taking place across the fleet sector1. 

Insurers are understandably competing hard for business today, but there will come a point when underwriting profitability becomes more important than premium growth. When that happens, behaviour typically changes. Early signs of that shift are already emerging in market conversations.

 

Where pressure could emerge first

The most immediate pressure is likely to be felt within the more challenging areas of the fleet market. Haulage and logistics, waste and recycling, courier and fleets with challenging claims experience are likely to attract greater attention, long before insurers significantly revisit their appetite for cleaner car and van fleets. However, even within those cleaner car and van fleets, the term “inflationary increase” may start to reappear during renewal negotiations.

Over the last two years, increased competition has encouraged some insurers to move beyond their traditional underwriting comfort zones in pursuit of growth. In many cases, that has improved outcomes for brokers and their clients. The question is whether that appetite remains when profitability comes under pressure.

Motor fleet risks

For brokers, that distinction matters. Whilst few would argue against taking advantage of today’s competitive conditions, understanding the quality of insurer appetite is becoming increasingly important. There is a big difference between an insurer building a sustainable portfolio and one pursuing short-term growth.

 

 

The market conversation is changing

Having spent much of the last year observing the market, listening to partner brokers and insurers across the market, one thing strikes me. The market remains enthusiastic about the future, but the conversations are changing.

Discussions once dominated by growth ambitions and new business opportunities are increasingly turning towards underwriting performance, claims inflation and long-term profitability. “It can’t continue” is a phrase I hear with increasing regularity.

The fleet market remains competitive, and many brokers continue to achieve excellent renewal outcomes for their clients. I do not believe the market is about to turn overnight, but I do think the direction of travel is changing.

But if history teaches us anything, it is that market cycles rarely announce themselves with a fanfare or parade. Change usually begins quietly, through a series of small shifts that may only become obvious in retrospect.

From my perspective, those signs are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

 

Scott Mills, Commercial Development Lead

Scott brings 34 years of London Market experience, with a career rooted in leadership and broking across both corporate and privately owned London Market Wholesale Brokerages.

Connect on LinkedIn

1Oxbow Partners UK Motor Market Report 2026

 

The views expressed are those of the author at the time of writing and are based on current market observations. Market conditions may change and no assurance is given that any future trends or outcomes described will occur.